Old-Fashioned Test Prep That Works: A Proven Approach for Middle and High School English


Let me let you in on a little secret: I actually like test prep season! I don't love that students have to take the tests (we can discuss that another day), but what I love is that this time is when we can slow down and reflect. There's no more pressure to teach new material, and it's also a signal that the end of the year is near! However, I know that means students are also super close to done and prepping for tests can really start to wear them thin. That’s why I stick to test prep strategies that work—no fluff, no gimmicks, just solid, old-fashioned review. While flashy new methods come and go, the classic approach still delivers results. By focusing on structured review, targeted practice, and immediate feedback, we can keep students engaged without burning them out. Here’s how to make test prep both effective and manageable.

1. Teach and Review Test Strategies

Before diving into content review, equip students with test-taking strategies that improve their confidence and accuracy. It seems like a  simple concept, but that's actually the good news: This part of test prep isn't difficult!


Teach skills like

  • eliminating wrong answers
  • managing time effectively
  • annotating passages
  • understanding question types
  • reading the extra information provided with passages (titles, authors, context, definitions)
  • reading the passages fully to get main ideas and big concepts
  • discerning unfamiliar words with context clues


A quick refresher on multiple-choice strategies, constructed responses, and essay structure ensures success because students are prepared for any format.

Test Prep Strategies Bell Ringers

2. Use a Review Game for Skill Practice

You and your students have spent all semester (or all year!) doing the hard work—now it’s time to lock in that learning. Playing interactive review games isn’t just about having fun; it’s about boosting engagement, reinforcing key concepts, and giving students a low-pressure way to recall information. Research shows that games activate the brain’s reward system, increase motivation, and help with long-term retention. Plus, as the end of the year nears and energy starts to dip, games can be the perfect way to keep students focused and motivated while still reviewing essential content!


Some of my favorite review games include


Gamifying test prep doesn't have to be a ton of work either! You might spend a little time of the front end setting the games up, but then you've got them done to use over and over. Or just make your practice tests a team competition! When students are competing, collaborating, and genuinely excited to participate, that’s authentic engagement at its best—making test prep feel less like a chore and more like a challenge they’re eager to conquer!

3. Provide Practice in Test Format

Students need to practice in the exact format they’ll see on test day, so there are no surprises. I share about my own experience with practicing in "test prep" format in my "What I Learned About Test Prep from my Handgun Training Course" blog post. Hop over and read that here! Use editable test prep assessments that mirror the structure and wording of real exams. Include multiple-choice, short response, and extended writing prompts so students build stamina and familiarity with expectations. If tests are online, provide that format of practice, too,  because in that case, students make have to type their answers or use different formatting options provided in the online testing platform.


One other note to mention here specifically for tests with writing portion - show students models and unpack those. I like to use my Sample Paper Analysis Task Cards to help students zero in on the most important takeaways.


4. Review the Answers—The Right Way

Going over answers isn’t just about grading—it’s about analyzing mistakes and understanding reasoning. In fact, I rarely take a grade during test prep.  Walk students through incorrect answers, have them explain their thinking, and use error analysis techniques to prevent repeat mistakes.


Some strategies for reviewing answers include:


5. How Much Time Should You Spend on Test Prep?

The ideal amount of review time depends on the complexity of the test and student needs, but a balanced approach is key. Too little review leaves students unprepared, while too much can lead to burnout. I usually plan to finish instruction about two weeks prior to the testing window.  One week, if things are rushed.  This time frame allows time for strategy instruction, skill reinforcement, practice, and reflection—without overwhelming students.

In Conclusion

Effective test prep doesn’t have to be complicated. By following these steps—teaching strategies, reviewing with games, practicing in test format, and analyzing answers/providing immediate feedback—you’ll set your students up for success. My students love to remind me I’m old, but sometimes a little old-fashioned prep—like solid practice and review—is exactly what they need to feel confident on test day.



To save you time, I’ve put together a ready-to-use test prep capsule that includes everything you need: editable assessments, review games, strategy guides, and practice materials designed specifically for middle and high school English. Grab it now and take the stress out of test prep!



Love this content?

Sign up for my email newsletter with more tips, ideas, success stories, and freebies!


Back-to-School Teacher Tips Inspired by My Trip to NYC, Classroom Management, Classroom Culture

5 Classroom Management and Teaching Strategies I Learned from My Trip to New York City

By Julie Faulkner • July 22, 2025
Back-to-school teacher tips inspired by NYC! From classroom management to student engagement, here are 5 teaching strategies and creative ways to start the year strong that I learned from my trip to NYC!
No-Prep High School & Middle School ELA Bell Ringers for Every Day

No-Prep High School & Middle School ELA Bell Ringers for Every Day of the Year

By Julie Faulkner • July 15, 2025
If you're an ELA teacher looking for consistent, no-prep bell ringers for the entire year for middle or high school students, this post is your goldmine. With 36 weeks of grammar practice, writing prompts, poetry analysis, or reading comprehension activities, you’ll have your entire year of bell ringers planned!
Plant-Themed, Growth Mindset High School Classroom Design Makeover

Plant-Themed, Growth Mindset High School Classroom Design Makeover

By Julie Faulkner • June 30, 2025
If you're searching for classroom makeover ideas, growth mindset decor, or creative ways to organize your room for maximum impact, this plant-themed high school English classroom transformation is packed with inspiration.
Effective Strategies for Teaching Poetry in Secondary ELA

No More 'IDK': Effective Strategies for Teaching Poetry in Secondary ELA

By Julie Faulkner • April 6, 2025
Tired of hearing “I don’t get it” every time you teach a poem? This blog post shares 5 teacher-tested strategies that build student confidence before the confusion kicks in. From guided annotations to smart poem pairings, these moves help students approach poetry with curiosity instead of panic. Think: less frustration, more “aha!” moments.
Mastering Academic Feedback on Writing

Mastering Academic Feedback on Writing: Strategies for Teachers and Students

By Julie Faulkner • January 2, 2025
Providing effective academic feedback on writing is one of the most impactful ways educators can support student growth. Research and experience consistently show that timely, meaningful feedback clarifies expectations and helps students develop critical skills for success in writing and beyond. Whether you’re following evaluation rubrics like TEAM or preparing students for AP Language standards or EOC writing tests, creating a system for giving and receiving feedback is essential. In this post, I’ll summarize five key strategies to make academic feedback a game-changer in your classroom.
Student-Centered Teaching Strategies: Engage Your Class Without the Stress

Student-Centered Teaching Strategies: Engage Your Class Without the Stress

By Julie Faulkner • November 27, 2024
There are those times when "teachering" just isn’t optimal. What do I mean by that? "Teachering," as defined by me, involves delivering new material, expecting students to produce immediate results, or spending the entire class in direct instruction when students are already overloaded or overstimulated. These times include—but are not limited to—the days before a break, the holiday season, the week of a full moon, half days, or even the day after Halloween. During these moments, the best approach is to shift the focus away from you and onto your students. Let them lead, apply what they’ve already learned, reflect on their progress, and take ownership of their work. This hands-off teaching strategy creates a structured yet low-stress classroom environment where students stay calm, focused, and productive.
Insights from a Student Teacher of High School English

Insights from a Student Teacher of High School English

July 25, 2024
It’s a unique situation for both parties of a student-teaching experience: on the one hand from the point of view of the student teacher, you are entering someone else’s classroom and you may be teaching solo for the first time, and on the other hand, you may be the classroom teacher who is welcoming someone else into your classroom to take the lead. To say the least, this is a tricky space to navigate. That’s why I thought it would be interesting to speak directly to a student teacher – to hear her thoughts and experiences. Whether you are a cooperating/mentoring teacher of a student teacher or you are a student teacher heading into the classroom, this interview with a student teacher of high school English (Miss M), who just completed her placement, is very enlightening.
Everything You Need to Know About How to Sell the Yearbook

Everything You Need to Know About How to Sell the Yearbook

July 25, 2024
You’ve worked hard for half a year or longer to create this beautiful time capsule — the yearbook. You’ve sold advertisements, taken pictures, written headlines and captions, and included as many students as possible. BUT — what if no one sees what you and your staffers have created? That may be a little hyperbolic, but it is super important to have a strategy in place not just for creating the yearbook but for selling it as well. Here’s everything you need to know about how to sell the yearbook!
Make Your Yearbook More Diverse & Inlcusive with These Easy Tips

Make Your Yearbook More Diverse & Inlcusive with These Easy Tips

July 25, 2024
Our yearbook staff’s motto is “Everybody’s Story. Everybody’s Book.” That means everyone! Not just the seniors, the athletes, the staffers and their friends, certain cliques – everybody. Why does that matter? For one, if we are creating a book for people to purchase, they need to be reflected in it; or they won’t purchase it. But the bigger, more important reason is simply that we are telling the story of a year, and without every person represented, considered, and included in the yearbook design, we haven’t done our job: We haven’t told the true story of the year at all if we let bias or favoritism creep in or if we get lazy with coverage and choices. The yearbook must be an accurate time capsule with reflections of each person’s interests, styles, talents, abilities, and backgrounds. Therefore, you can make your yearbook more diverse and inclusive with these easy steps! Tips for your yearbook pages and beyond.
Planning the First Week of Yearbook Class

Planning the First Week of Yearbook Class

July 25, 2024
You’ve just been assigned the yearbook, or last year didn’t go so well, and you want your first days plans to be solid, effective, and fun! Does this sound like you? I’ve been there. The first week of school is a whirlwind, but in yearbook class, the first week back to school is even more topsy turvy, to say the least. You might have looked through my Tips for New Advisers post or How to Have a Picture-Perfect Start to the Year posts for adviser-facing suggestions, and you feel good-to-go from that side of things. However, now it’s time to decide what to do when students are walking through the door — AKA planning the first week of yearbook class! When I think about what to do the first week of school in my yearbook class, I try to think of it like one my English classes in some ways, and in other ways, it is completely different! In this blog post, I’ll share my student-facing plans for the first week of yearbook class.